Every winter, drivers face the same choice: stop ice from forming in the first place, or deal with it in the morning. A windshield snow cover and an ice scraper solve the same problem in two very different ways. Here's how they compare.
How a windshield snow cover works
A snow cover is a large, weather-resistant sheet that you put over the windshield in the evening. Flaps that close inside the front doors keep it in place overnight. In the morning you pull it off, shake off the snow and frost, and the glass underneath is clear.
Pros:
- No scraping at all on the windshield
- You can drive away almost immediately
- Works as a sun shade in summer
- Protects the glass and wipers from ice build-up
Cons:
- You have to remember to put it on the night before
- Covers the windshield only, not the side windows or mirrors
- A wet cover needs somewhere to go – the trunk works fine
See the Windshield Snow & Frost Cover →
How an ice scraper works
An ice scraper removes ice after it has formed. A manual scraper is cheap and simple, but on thick ice it takes time and effort. An electric ice scraper uses a powered head to make the job easier and faster, and can be recharged with USB.
Pros:
- Always ready, no planning needed
- Works on every window and the mirrors
- Small enough for the glove box or door pocket
Cons:
- You still have to stand outside in the cold
- Thick ice takes longer to remove
- An electric scraper needs to be charged now and then
See the Rechargeable Electric Ice Scraper →
Quick comparison
| Snow cover | Ice scraper | |
|---|---|---|
| Time in the morning | Under a minute | Several minutes |
| Planning needed | Yes, the night before | No |
| Side windows & mirrors | No | Yes |
| Use in summer | Yes, as a sun shade | No |
So which one should you choose?
- Choose a snow cover if you park outside overnight and want to skip scraping the windshield on most mornings.
- Choose an ice scraper if you often park in different places or just need a quick fix for the times ice does form.
- Choose both if you live somewhere with long, cold winters. The cover keeps the windshield clear, and the scraper handles side windows, mirrors and the nights you forget the cover.
Get both in one kit
Most drivers in cold climates end up using both. Our Winter Car Kit includes the windshield snow & frost cover and the rechargeable electric ice scraper, for less than buying them separately, with free shipping.
Want more tips? Read How to Stop Your Windshield From Freezing: 5 Simple Tips.
